Why Shoot a Butler? by Georgette Heyer


print
Frank Amberley was lost on back roads on the way to his uncle’s house when he stumbled upon a beautiful woman standing next to a car with a dead man inside.  She’s holding a gun, but maintains that she didn’t do it.  He believes her and doesn’t mention her when he reports the murder to the police.  He doesn’t have much faith in the village police and is intrigued by this young woman, so he begins to investigate.  Eventually the police officially ask him to join their investigation.

This is a nice country house mystery set in the 1930s.  Heyer deftly shows the difference in class between the servants and the aristocrats in this novel and it was interesting to read a twist on the classic “the butler did it” mystery cliché.

Georgette Heyer is known for her dialogue and it really shines here.  She uses it to flesh out the characters and she is one of the few authors that leaves me laughing out loud.

The one thing that bothered me about this mystery was that Amberley is very secretive, even with the readers.  This caused a very long exposition scene at the end of the novel where he explained every step he took in the investigation.  The reader doesn’t really have a chance to solve the mystery with him.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.